St. Charles falls in OHSAA Division I boys soccer state final

Told his team almost tripled Kettering Fairmont in total shots during the Division I boys soccer state final Nov. 15, St. Charles coach Chris Vonau could do little more than shake his head in frustration.
The Cardinals earned a handful of quality scoring chances in outshooting Fairmont 23-8, but the first-time state finalist Firebirds sent St. Charles to a 3-1 loss at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field and its second state runner-up finish in three seasons.
 
The Cardinals were seeking their first title since 1985.
 
“We got chances. We made some adjustments with how we wanted to develop our offense, but this game stinks sometimes,” Vonau said. “This game, taking nothing away from Fairmont and what they earned, but any game in which you get [more than] double the amount of shots, you think you would have a couple goals to show for it. But it didn’t work out.”
Azariyah Nsabimama and Aaron Black scored 12 minutes apart in the first half for Fairmont (15-5-3), and St. Charles (18-4-1) lost for the first time since its regular-season finale Oct. 15 against Worthington Kilbourne.
St. Charles had outscored its first five tournament opponents 15-3, including a 1-0 win over defending state champion Dublin Jerome in a state semifinal Nov. 11.
 
Senior forward Sam Lofthouse scored St. Charles’ only goal, spinning and shooting from about 25 yards to the right of the goal with 25:35 to play and sneaking his shot into the upper-right corner.
“I just put it on target, but it wasn’t enough for today,” said Lofthouse, who also had the only goal of the state semifinal.
 
That made it 2-1, but Fairmont got the goal back less than four minutes later.
 
Gavin Weaver’s corner kick got all the way through traffic, and Luke Davidson put it in from right in front.
Vonau credited at least some of the Cardinals’ offensive struggles to Fairmont’s success in crowding the midfield.
 
“This game gives and it takes and we were on the taking side tonight,” St. Charles senior midfielder AJ Boiarsky said.
 
Fairmont coach Neil Craft highlighted his team’s efficiency when told the shot disparity, also noting that the Firebirds overcame going 0-5-1 in a six-game stretch from mid-September to early October.
 
“Our defense did a great job of absorbing pressure in the right areas and making them settle for low-quality, low-efficiency shots,” Craft said. “They got into zone 14 a little bit too much for my liking, but our central defensive midfielders did a great job working in tandem and denying those entry passes to specifically Boiarsky and Lofthouse in particular. We knew they were lethal threats from inside and outside the box.
 
“St. Charles is organized and well coached, but we had the better of the match.”
 
St. Charles was in its fourth consecutive state tournament, capping a run for a senior class that went 55-22-10. But several underclassmen contributed, including sophomore goalie Micah Neil, who made three saves.
Fairmont’s Carson Dewald stopped six shots.
 
St. Charles also was state runner-up in 2024, 2016, 1991, 1988 and 1981.
 
“This senior class has done something that is exceptionally hard to do,” Vonau said. “The path they have blazed is very, very, very hard. They have nothing to hang their heads about.”
 
Dave Purpura
Columbus Dispatch
Nov. 15, 2026Updated Nov. 16, 2026, 8:11 a.m. ET
Back
St. Charles Preparatory School admits students of any race, color, national and ethnic origin to all the rights, privileges, programs, and activities made available to students at the school. It does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national and ethnic origin in administration of its educational policies, admissions policies, scholarship and loan programs, and athletic and other school-administered programs.

St. Charles Preparatory School will not discriminate on the basis of race, color, or ethnic origin in the hiring of its certified or non-certified personnel.